Introduction
In many traditions, the suffering of Yeshua (Jesus) is understood primarily as the physical torment of the crucifixion. A deeper mystical reflection, however, suggests that Yeshua’s true suffering is not the bodily pain on the cross, but a metaphysical degradation, a spiritual torment brought about by his posthumous idolization. From a Jewish perspective, to worship a human as God is a profound distortion, one that would cause the soul of that person immense anguish. This essay explores that idea through Talmudic imagery, Kabbalistic symbolism, the archetype of Yosef (Joseph), and the concept of the scapegoat. In doing so, we find a framework in which Yeshua remains a defender of Israel even within a distorted legacy. Ultimately, when “every knee shall bow,” it is envisioned not as an act of deification, but as one of remorse and acknowledgment, paving a path toward reconciliation that does not compromise monotheism.
Talmudic Imagery: Boiling in Filth, the Real Torment
One of the most striking Talmudic images of the afterlife is “Tzoah Rotachat”, boiling excrement . In Gittin 56b–57a, the Talmud relates a story about Onkelos summoning the spirits of various figures, including “Yeshu the Nazarene” (identified by commentators as Jesus). Onkelos asks Yeshua, “What is your punishment in the next world?” Yeshua’s spirit replies: “Boiling in excrement”, explaining that this fate is because he “mocked the words of the sages” . This grotesque image is not describing physical suffering in a literal cauldron; it is a metaphysical metaphor. In rabbinic literature, excrement represents utter unholiness, the antithesis of divine wisdom. The Talmud explicitly notes the irony that while the gentile prophet Balaam sought to curse Israel, “Jesus the Nazarene, who was a Jewish “sinner”, sought their well-being” . In other words, despite his sins, Yeshua’s intention as a Jew was to protect and bless his people, yet his soul is immersed in “filth” as a consequence of how his legacy deviated into idolatry.
This Talmudic passage sets the stage: Yeshua’s true suffering is depicted as spiritual. The filthy boiling cauldron symbolizes the degradation of being misidentified as a god. To a pious Jewish soul, nothing could be more agonizing than being the cause of others’ idolatry. The physical crucifixion, horrific as it was, lasted but hours, whereas this metaphysical humiliation has persisted for centuries in the theological error surrounding his name. Thus, the sages encoded in stark imagery the idea that Yeshua’s soul is, as it were, immersed in the impurity of false worship. His “boiling excrement” punishment is a visceral symbol for the spiritual mire of idolatrous adulation.
Kabbalistic Symbolism: Exile in the “Other Side”
Jewish mysticism (Kabbalah) delves further into the meaning of this suffering. Kabbalistic commentators explain that Tzoah Rotachat (the boiling filth) represents a spiritual plane where impurity reigns. Rabbi Joseph Karo, in his mystical work Maggid Mesharim, teaches that the soul of one who falls into great heresy is consigned to the spiritual “excrement” to become nourishment for the forces of impurity (the sitra achra, or “Other Side”) . Just as the human body excretes waste to expel what it cannot use, providing fertilizer for lowly organisms, so too heaven decrees that a corrupted soul becomes sustenance for spiritual forces of darkness . In this light, Yeshua’s post-mortem fate of “boiling in excrement” signifies that his spiritual essence has been harnessed by the realm of impurity. The holiness of a Jewish soul, which should have been elevated in pure service to God, is instead trapped in a foul vessel, empowering unclean ideologies that draw strength from his distorted worship.
Rabbi Judah Loew of Prague (the Maharal) further elaborates that excrement is the polar opposite of holy wisdom. He writes that one who mocks or rejects divine truth is judged in Tzoah Rotachat precisely because this filth is “the antithesis of godly knowledge and presence” . It is the natural consequence for a Jew who chooses idol worship or shituf (association of others with God) . In Yeshua’s case, even if he himself did not choose to be deified, his legacy of shituf (the Trinitarian idea associating a human with God) drags his soul into that unholy realm. Kabbalistically, one might say Yeshua’s soul is in exile among the klipot (impure husks). His identity has been clad in the “garments of Edom”, the trappings of Roman religion, much like the Jewish Shekhinah (Divine Presence) is said to be in exile when Israel is in exile. Yeshua’s plight is a cosmic tragedy: a spark of Israel caught in the very “Other Side” he sought to overcome.
Yet, even in the depths of this spiritual exile, the Talmud reminds us that Yeshua “sought [Israel’s] well-being.” This hints at a redemptive spark still buried in the filth. Maharal notes that Yeshua is contrasted with Balaam: one a Jew who “sinned” yet ultimately defended his people, the other a gentile prophet who tried to destroy them . The mystical implication is that Yeshua’s soul retains a core of loyalty to Israel, even as it suffers within the very idolatry that wronged both him and God. Kabbalists often speak of holy sparks trapped in dark shells, awaiting redemption. We can view Yeshua as such a spark, a Jewish soul whom history enclosed in a shell of divinity that is not his, left to “boil” until the shell is cracked and truth released.
The Yosef Archetype: Betrayal, Disguise, and Forgiveness
The Hebrew Bible provides a powerful template for this narrative in the story of Yosef (Joseph). Yosef, beloved son of Jacob, was betrayed by his brothers, sold into slavery, and presumed dead. In Egypt, he rose to unexpected power, disguising his true identity behind an Egyptian name and appearance. When famine struck, Yosef, now viceroy of Egypt, was the very one who saved his family. The parallels between Yosef and Yeshua are striking and deliberate in this mystical reading:
• Betrayal by Brothers: Yosef was cast away by his own brothers; Yeshua, a son of Israel, was rejected by many of his brethren and handed over to gentile authorities.
• Descent and Ascent: Yosef descended into a pit and bondage before ascending to rule in a foreign land. Yeshua descended into death and (as Christians believe) ascended in a resurrection, coming to “rule” spiritually over a vast gentile empire.
• Disguised Among Gentiles: Yosef took on the garb and language of Egypt, his brothers did not recognize him. Yeshua’s image likewise took on the garb of Rome; to Jews, he became almost unrecognizable, portrayed with European features, associated with a foreign theology.
• Saving Lives: Yosef declared to his brothers, “Although you intended me harm, God intended it for good, so as to bring about… the survival of many people” . What appeared as a tragedy was in fact God’s plan to save lives. In an analogous way, Yeshua’s betrayal and death, however tragic, resulted in a new religious movement that turned countless gentiles away from paganism towards the God of Israel (albeit through a distorted lens). In Rabbi Yaakov Emden’s words, “the Nazarene brought about a double kindness in the world… on the other hand, he did much good for the Gentiles by doing away with idolatry and removing images from their midst” . The very misfortune of Yeshua’s rejection became the vehicle by which the nations learned of Israel’s Scriptures and moral law.
• Reconciliation and Forgiveness: In the climax of Yosef’s story, he reveals himself to his trembling brothers. They bow before him and beg forgiveness, saying “We are your slaves”.
Yosef responds with tears, forgiving them and recognizing God’s providence: “Fear not… Am I in the place of God? Although you intended me harm, God intended it for good… to save many lives” . The brothers’ bow was an act of remorse and submission, not worship. So too, we can envision a future where Yeshua is “revealed” not as a disguised Egyptian deity, but as a son of Israel. Those who had worshiped him will finally recognize his true identity and bow not in deification, but in repentance, remorseful and grateful that through his story, God brought about a greater good.
Yosef’s saga, in this mystical framework, foreshadows Yeshua’s. Both are scapegoated saviors: innocents betrayed, who nonetheless become instruments of salvation for others. And crucially, both remain loyal to their people. Yosef never stopped loving his brothers or identifying as Hebrew, even when he looked Egyptian. We suggest that Yeshua, in his celestial vantage, similarly has never abandoned his people. The Talmud’s Onkelos story has Yeshua instruct, “Seek their (the Jews’) welfare, do not seek their harm, for whoever touches them touches the apple of God’s eye” . This is Yosef’s voice: a hidden brother protecting his family from behind a foreign throne.
Scapegoat and Sacrifice: Bearing the Collective Burden
Another key concept is the scapegoat (Se’ir La’Azazel) of Yom Kippur. In the ancient Temple ritual, two goats were chosen: one was offered to God, and the other, the scapegoat, had the sins of the people placed upon its head and was sent away into the wilderness, to Azazel, a desolate place . This scapegoat carried Israel’s impurities into the nether regions, removing the community’s guilt by absorbing it and disappearing into the wild.
The scapegoat is a powerful archetype for Yeshua’s role in Christian theology and, intriguingly, in this mystical Jewish reading. Yeshua was effectively cast out of the camp, crucified outside the walls of Jerusalem, like the scapegoat banished to the desert. Upon him were placed the transgressions and burdens of others: according to Christian belief, the sins of humanity. In a historical sense, he also became a scapegoat for blame: generations of gentiles would later fault “the Jews” for his death, tragically persecuting the very people he sought to defend. In a spiritual sense, we can say the idolatry of the nations was heaped upon Yeshua’s shoulders. They made him into a deity, placing on him the weight of their theological errors, much as the Israelites symbolically placed their iniquities on the goat’s head. He then was sent off into the spiritual wilderness of Azazel. That is, handed over to the realm of demons and impurity, as the Talmud portrays with the boiling excrement imagery.
What is the outcome of the scapegoat’s journey? In the Yom Kippur ritual, the goat’s descent to Azazel carried away the people’s sins, allowing Israel to begin anew with a clean slate . By analogy, Yeshua’s being made a scapegoat had a paradoxical effect: it allowed gentiles to abandon their old sins of idolatry (Zeus, Apollo, and the like were forsaken) and feel atoned, as they embraced the story of a single sacrificed redeemer. In doing so, they unwittingly came closer to Israel’s God (even as they introduced new complexities).
From a mystical vantage, Yeshua’s soul accepted the role of the scapegoat, bearing others’ projections and sins, which is itself a form of suffering for the sake of others. This resonates with the Kabbalistic idea of the “suffering servant” or Mashiach ben Yosef concept, wherein a messianic figure suffers to atone for the generation. While mainstream rabbinic thought does not assign this role to Jesus, our exploration allows that Yeshua’s fate mirrors that trope. He became the sacrificial lamb in the eyes of the world, “taking on” the spiritual maladies of many. This was not to elevate him to divinity, but perhaps to catalyze a process by which those maladies could eventually be purged. In being cast to Azazel (the Other Side), Yeshua drew the darkness to himself, and there his soul has been wrestling with it ever since, in boiling anguish, awaiting the day those sins are finally lifted.
A Distorted Legacy: Yeshua as Defender of Israel
Even as Yeshua has been venerated in un-Jewish ways, a thread in both Talmud and later Jewish commentary portrays him as a defender of Israel. The Talmud’s account of Yeshua’s spirit instructing Onkelos to “seek the welfare” of Israel and warning that harming Israel is striking God’s own eye  is remarkable. It depicts Yeshua, despite personal punishment, advocating for his people’s honor. The text even says: “Come and see the difference: Balaam, a prophet of the nations, wished Israel harm, whereas Yeshua the Nazarene, a sinner of Israel, sought their well-being” . In the eyes of the Talmud, whatever Yeshua’s errors, his loyalty to Israel was never in question.
Through the centuries of Christian history, Yeshua’s name was unfortunately used to justify anti-Jewish persecutions, a bitter irony if ever there was one. Yet one might say that was not Yeshua’s doing, but the sin of those who “knew not what they did.” If we separate the historical Yeshua from the later actions of some followers, we can maintain that Yeshua the Jew would abhor the mistreatment of Jews. Indeed, many Christians today, reflecting on their faith’s Jewish roots, have come to defend and love Israel, seeing the Jews as Jesus’s own people. This trend can be viewed as Yeshua’s positive influence re-emerging: even through a distorted legacy, a love for Israel shines through in segments of his followers.
Rabbi Yaakov Emden in the 18th century went so far as to suggest a divine purpose in Christianity, writing that Jesus’ intent was not to abolish the Torah for Jews but to bring the Gentiles to observe basic monotheism and morality . Emden praised Jesus for “strengthening the Torah of Moses” (by affirming its eternal value) and guiding gentiles away from idol-worship to the God of heaven . In Emden’s remarkable view, Yeshua actually performed a service to Israel by spreading knowledge of Israel’s God and Scriptures worldwide. Similarly, Maimonides wrote that although Christianity (and Islam) are based on errors, “ultimately, all the deeds of Jesus of Nazareth… serve to prepare the way for the Messiah’s coming and to improve the entire world, motivating the nations to serve God together” . In other words, what appears as a distortion can be part of a larger divine plan: Yeshua’s distorted legacy still familiarized the world with the concepts of one God, Scripture, and Messiah, paving the road for a future age when all recognize the truth. In that future, the defense of Israel that Yeshua always maintained will manifest as the nations honor Israel openly.
From a mystical standpoint, we can imagine Yeshua’s soul yearning for this rectification. As a defender of Israel, he would want his followers to cease any hostility and acknowledge the Jewish people’s role. We have already seen the beginnings of this: many Christians repudiate the charge of deicide against Jews, seek forgiveness, and affirm that God’s covenant with Israel stands. These developments, essentially, are Yeshua “defending” Israel’s dignity in the hearts of his believers. The more the church returns to the ethical monotheism Yeshua originally taught, the more his soul is soothed. Each time a Christian rejects anti-Semitism or idolatry (such as worshipping statues), that boiling cauldron cools a little. Yeshua’s advocacy for his people, in heaven and earth, works to ensure that his legacy will finally bless Israel, not curse it.
“Every Knee Shall Bow”, Remorse and Acknowledgment, Not Deification
Both Jewish and Christian scriptures speak of a time of universal recognition. The prophet Isaiah, echoed by Paul in the New Testament, foresaw that “every knee shall bow” to God (and in Christian reading, to Jesus). What does it mean for all to bow? In our framework, this future bowing is not the worship of a man, but the humbling of humanity in acknowledgment of truth. It is the scene of Joseph and his brothers replayed on a cosmic scale.
When Joseph’s brothers came before him in Egypt, “they threw themselves down before him” and said, “We are your slaves” . This was the fulfillment of Yosef’s youthful dream of his brothers’ sheaves bowing to his, but its meaning was now clear: contrition, not adulation. They did not mistake Joseph for God; they bowed because they regretted their betrayal and recognized Joseph’s God-given role. Joseph immediately redirected their focus to Hashem, saying, “Am I in place of God? … It was God’s plan for good” . The bowing was the necessary human response to having been so wrong, a gesture of honor and remorse toward the one they wronged, while credit for salvation remained with God.
Analogously, we envision that in the end of days, when truth is revealed, all nations will bow toward Yeshua, not to proclaim him a god, but to apologize and make amends. They will bow in recognition that this Jewish man was unjustly elevated to divinity and used as a wedge between them and Israel. It will be an act of collective teshuvah (repentance): a way of saying, “We are your servants; we wronged you and your people.” And just as Yosef comforted his brothers, Yeshua will lift up those bowing and redirect all honor to the One God. In this redemptive moment, Yeshua’s role will be understood properly, not as a rival to God, but as an instrument of God. Every tongue will acknowledge, not that Yeshua is God, but that Yeshua served God. The remorseful bowing affirms God’s justice (that no human should have been deified) and God’s mercy (that even this error was turned to good).
Such an interpretation allows Christians to bow before Yeshua figuratively by admitting the theological mistake of deification, and allows Jews to join in that moment by acknowledging Yeshua’s positive contributions. It transforms a potential point of idolatry into a moment of profound reconciliation. All humanity bows together, unified in humility under the sovereignty of the One God. No one is bowing to Yeshua as an idol; rather, all are bowing with Yeshua, so to speak, before the God of Israel, the God whom Yeshua himself bowed to in prayer during his life.
Toward a Mystical Reconciliation, One God, One People
This mystical reflection offers a framework for interreligious healing between Judaism and Christianity. It asks both sides to see Yeshua in a new light: not as a divisive deity or a false messiah, but as a suffering brother whose story can ultimately unite us in worship of the one true God. For Jews, this means recognizing that Yeshua’s Jewish soul and intentions were not to destroy his people, in fact, he remains our brother Yosef, whose bones have been carried through a long exile in foreign hands, awaiting return. It means understanding that the Christian adoration of Jesus, while theologically misguided for us, sprang from a groping for Israel’s God and values. There is, therefore, a spark of holiness in it that can be uplifted, once separated from the dross of idolatry.
For Christians, this framework invites a reexamination of what it means to “love Jesus.” If Yeshua’s deepest desire is the honor of the Father and the welfare of Israel, then to truly love him is to reject the idolatry done in his name (worshipping him as equal to God) and to embrace his people Israel rather than denigrate them. It means, perhaps, transitioning from seeing Jesus as the endpoint of worship to seeing him as a means to the Higher End, the One God he called Father. Such a shift need not destroy Christian faith; rather, it could fulfill it, as the first of the Ten Commandments and the Shema (“the Lord is One”) take their rightful central place, and Jesus is respected as teacher, prophet, even messianic agent, but not God incarnate. This maintains absolute monotheism (Ein Od Milvado, “there is none besides Him”) while not dismissing the spiritual experiences Christians have had through Jesus. It reframes those experiences as encounters with the divine Presence through the story of Yeshua, rather than with Yeshua as God.
Mystically, we may say that when this reconciliation and clarification occurs, Yeshua’s soul will finally be released from Gehenna’s boiling excrement. The idolatrous “filth” will be cleansed away, leaving only the purified truth of his legacy. No longer sustaining the sitra achra, his soul can ascend in peace, having completed its mission. In the language of the Zohar, the soul is cleansed of the “filth of this world” and brought up, while the filth itself remains below . Humanity’s act of collective teshuvah, setting aside false theology, would remove the filth from Yeshua, allowing whatever was true and holy in him to shine forth in service of God. And in that moment, we might imagine Yeshua echoing the words of Yosef: “Do not fear. God has turned it all to good.”
In conclusion, the true suffering of Yeshua has been the long nightmare of deification, a burden he never wanted. But within that dark reality was hidden a divine plan, much as Yosef’s descent into slavery was necessary for a later salvation. By contemplating Yeshua’s suffering as metaphysical rather than physical, and by drawing on Talmudic and Kabbalistic insights, we uncover a narrative of redemption and brotherhood. Yeshua, like Yosef, estranged from his brethren, becomes the instrument to sustain the world and ultimately reconcile the family. All the world will come to bow, not in idolatry, but in remorseful unity, and Yeshua himself will rejoice to surrender all crowns to the One True King. In that day, the mist will clear, the idol will vanish, and Yeshua the tortured brother will be Yosef, “added”, back to his people. And God will be One and His Name One, as all nations join Israel in pure worship.